Highway Performance Monitoring System
|FHWA > Policy Information > HPMS > HPMS Field Manual > Appendix G: Reporting Travel Data in Air Quality Nonattainment and Maintenance Areas|
An update of the manual is available! - HPMS Field Manual, September 2010
HPMS Field Manual
Appendix G: Reporting Travel Data in Air Quality Nonattainment and Maintenance Areas
The HPMS is a consistent, efficient mechanism through which travel tracking information can be developed.To minimize burden and avoid duplication of efforts by States, MPOs, and local governments for travel monitoring and data reporting, EPA has chosen to rely on the HPMS as the principal tool for meeting the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA's) travel monitoring needs.
The requirements for travel estimates for National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) nonattainment areas as designated by EPA were developed in response to the Clean Air Act Amendments (CAAA) of 1990.Specific EPA travel monitoring requirements for designated NAAQS nonattainment areas can be found in Section 187, Vehicle Travel Forecasting and Tracking Guidance (Federal Register, March 19, 1992, Volume 57, No. 54).This guidance calls for States/MPOs having affected urbanized nonattainment areas to estimate total annual vehicular highway travel using HPMS procedures.
In addition, HPMS data are used to develop mobile source emission inventories that are produced by EPA, State, and local air agencies in the development of air quality plans and strategies.Specific guidance on the use of HPMS data in emission inventories can be found in "Volume IV: Chapter 2, Use of Locality-Specific Transportation Data for the Development of Mobile Source Emission Inventories," September 1996.
HPMS data are also used in establishing regional transportation-related emissions for transportation conformity purposes in accordance with the Transportation Conformity Rule, 40 CFR parts 51 and 93.Estimated vehicle-miles of travel (VMT) based on the HPMS are used for calibration and validation of base-year network-based travel models when required in nonattainment or maintenance areas.
For conformity purposes, locally developed county-based programs and other procedures different from the HPMS procedures are permitted subject to interagency consultation procedures.See 40 CFR Parts 51 and 93, Transportation Conformity Rule Amendments: Flexibility and Streamlining (Federal Register, August 15, 1997, Volume 62, N. 158) for further details. In general, it is the State's responsibility to negotiate specific departures from use of the HPMS to track travel change with EPA and FHWA field offices through the interagency consultation procedures cited above.Where HPMS is used for travel tracking purposes, States should establish the following in cooperation with EPA and FHWA field offices:
To meet the Clean Air Act requirements, travel data are to represent total travel within the NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance area boundary surrounding affected urbanized areas. The design of the HPMS permits its use for these purposes only in those NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance areas that contain one or more complete urbanized area(s) and typically for only one pollutant, unless the nonattainment boundaries are the same for multiple pollutants.The HPMS sample is not valid if the nonattainment or maintenance area does not contain a complete urbanized area or if parts of an urbanized area are included in multiple nonattainment or maintenance areas.Within any nonattainment or maintenance area boundary, the land area outside of the FHWA-approved adjusted urbanized area boundaries classified as rural or small urban (places between 5,000 to 49,999 population) is referred to as the donut area in this Manual.
There are many areas of the country designated nonattainment or maintenance for more than one pollutant.Each pollutant has its own nonattainment or maintenance are boundary, which often is not the same as for the other pollutant(s).HPMS is not designed to address more than one nonattianment or maintenance are boundary for a given urbanized area.
However, it should be noted that the use of the term "donut area" in the Manual is not the same as the definition of the term "donut areas" in the Transportation Conformity Rule (40 CFR 93.101).Under this rule, "donut areas" refer to the areas outside of a metropolitan planning area boundary, but inside the boundary of a nonattainment or maintenance area that contains any part of a metropolitan area.The transportation planning regulations define the metropolitan planning area boundary to cover at least the urbanized area and the contiguous geographic area likely to become urbanized within the next 20 years.As the urbqnized area boundary and the metropolitan planning area boundary are most likely not the same, the use of the term "donut area" in this Manual differs from that in the Conformity Rule and would most likely cover a different geographic area.
Travel estimates within NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance areas are derived using HPMS procedures for higher functional systems.However, it is important to note that procedures for estimating travel on the rural minor collector and local functional systems, while important for tracking nonattainment or maintenance area travel, are not specified in the Manual or by FHWA.Travel on these lower systems is developed using State and local methods and procedures and reported to the HPMS as summary data (see Chapter III).
Due to implementation of the new NAAQS, significant changes have occurred to nonattainment and maintenance areas.On April 30, 2004, EPS designated new nonattainment areas under the 8-hour ozone air quality standard, effective June 15, 2004.And, on January 5, 2005, EPA designated new nonattainment areas under the PM2.5 air quality standard, effective April 5, 2005.Nonattainment boundaries for these pollutants differ from each other, as well as existing nonattainment and maintenance areas.Therefore, sample panels and coding may need to be adjusted. In addition, on June 15, 2005, EPA revoked the 1-hour ozone air quality standard for most areas of the country. Therefore, 1-hour ozone nonattainment and maintenance boundaries for most areas1 are no longer applicable and should not be used as a basis for sample panels or coding.
In addition, several areas2 of the country are currently part of Early Action Compacts (EACs).Under EACs, EPA has deferred the 8-hour ozone nonattainment designation of these areas.Therefore, the donut area sampling procedures in this Appendix are not required for the 8-hour standard in these areas. However, States are encouraged to consult with State and local air agencies to ensure that appropriate travel data is available to meet air quality planning needs.
NAAQS Nonattainment/maintenance Area Codes
The three-digit urbanized area codes shown in Appendix B are used for nonattainment or maintenance area coding in HPMS.Assign NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance area codes (Item 16) following these general rules:
Use this coding consistently for summary data as well as for universe, standard sample, and supplementary sample sections.When the primary urbanized area in a nonattainment area is in another State, the assigned NAAQS nonattainment code must be for the primary urbanized area in the adjoining State.
An illustration of the Houston NAAQS nonattainment area is shown in Figure G-1. It consists of the urbanized areas of Houston (the primary urbanized area), Texas City, Galveston, a portion of a fictitious urbanized area (Bogusville), six small urban areas and the remaining rural area.Only all complete urbanized area, small urban area, and rural area sections entirely within the NAAQS nonattainment area are to be coded with the FHWA urbanized area code of Houston (015) as the nonattainment area code.The table below the Figure G-1 contains the proper coding for universe, standard sample, or supplementary sample sections and for required summary data fields.The fictitious urbanized area (Bogusville) is shown in Figure G-1 split by the Houston nonattainment area boundary.HPMS cannot be used to produce travel estimates that include split urbanized areas (Bogusville).This is due to the fact that the current HPMS sampling scheme does not allow for expanding travel data based on only part of an urbanized area that happens to lie in a given nonattainment area boundary.Therefore, the nonattainment area code for Bogusville (both the portion inside and outside the nonattainment area) must be coded "000".Any air quality travel analysis for the complete Houston NAAQS must be done outside of HPMS, since as described above, the Bogusville contribution to the total nonattainment VMT cannot be estimated in HPMS.
Figure G-1. Houston NAAQS Nonattainment/Maintenance Area
For all road segments outside of nonattainment or maintenance areas, code "000" in the nonattainment area data item.
Donut Area Sampling Procedures
The following discussion outlines procedures for developing a sample panel of highway sections that can be used to estimate travel for certain functional systems in the donut area of an NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance area.The donut area sample panel is a combination of existing standard sample sections and randomly selected supplementary sample sections in the donut area.
Donut area sample procedures use:
NAAQS nonattainment and maintenance area boundaries are defined in 40 CFR Part 81. These procedures also require an up-to-date functional classification of all roadways within the donut area. Finally, these procedures also depend on the existence of accurate length and road section information within the donut area boundary.The donut area sampling procedures apply only to roads functionally classified as rural and small urban minor arterial, rural major collector, and small urban collector within the donut area boundary.
For urbanized areas that are part of nonattainment or maintenance areas for multiple pollutants, the donut are sample panel should be based on the nonattainment or maintenance boundary for a single priority pollutant.An assumed priority of pollutants is as follows: ozone, PM2.5, CO, and PM10.If a different priority is assumed, this should be documented in the submittal comment file as part of the annual HPMS data submittal.For example, if an urbanized area is designated nonattainment for both ozone and PM2.5, but the boundaries are different, the sample panel should be based on the ozone boundary.If a State wants the panel to be based on PM2.5 instead, this is allowable but should be noted in the submittal letter.
Donut Area Boundary
The development of the donut area sample depends on established, up-to-date, and recognizable boundaries.The FHWA approved, adjusted urban area boundaries should be available on State or MPO maps.The nonattainment and maintenance are boundaries are defined in 40 CFR Part 81.The adjusted boundaries of urbanized and small urban areas in the nonattainment or maintenance area must be based on the latest Decennial Census.
Standard Sample Review
The donut area sample panel is comprised of:
The first step in designing a donut area sample panel is to optimize the standard sample panel using the HPMS sample adequacy software and the procedures described in Chapter VII and Appendices C and D.The donut area sampling methodology requires an up-to-date and error-free standard sample panel without boundary, volume group, or universe definition problems; the existing standard sample panel must also meet the established HPMS precision criteria.Proceeding to develop a donut area sample panel without a clean standard sample panel and a well-defined universe will result in inaccurate information.
Donut Area Sampling Universe
The universe to be sampled consists of all highway sections within State boundaries that are functionally classified as rural minor arterial, rural major collector, small urban minor arterial, and small urban collector.In addition, they are located within the defined nonattainment or maintenance boundary and are outside of all urbanized area boundaries.
In cases where donut areas cross State lines, all State portions must be sampled.The involved States should coordinate the sample size calculation using the whole donut area universe (all States combined), and then sample a minimum of each State's pro rata share of the required samples based on the existing universe length in each State for each donut functional system and volume group stratum.Expansion factors are developed based on the universe and sampled length within each individual State.
Donut Area Universe Stratification
The functional system strata are designed to maintain consistency with the standard sample, but combine rural and small urban sections for sampling efficiency.The donut area universe is stratified into two donut functional systems (donut minor arterial and donut collector) and five volume group stratifications.This results in 10 possible donut panel strata (two donut functional systems and five volume groups).
The donut minor arterial system consists of both the small urban and rural minor arterial systems.The donut collector system consists of the rural major collector and the small urban collector systems.The volume group strata have been defined to minimize the number of strata and help reduce the overall sample size.The volume group categories are as follows:
These volume groups should be representative of minor arterial and collector sections in most donut areas.In larger nonattainment and maintenance areas, Volume Group 5 may include a greater volume range than the lower volume groups.This will not pose a problem if the functional class definition used by the State conforms with the standard definition; where it does not, or where other special circumstances exist, the volume groups may be expanded or changed.If other volume groups are selected, the AADT limits of the volume groups must be reported to FHWA with the HPMS submittal.
Preparing the Donut Area Universe Sampling Frame
A universe sampling frame is a listing or file of all the sections from which a sample panel is selected.A complete inventory must be undertaken to determine the length of roadway in each stratum and to identify the universe sampling frame elements (sections). To create the sampling frame, all donut area roadways in the two donut area functional systems must be broken down into road sections by the five volume groups; samples will be selected from these strata.The information needed for each road section includes:
Since the donut area sample is used for estimating travel, each universe sampling frame section should be as homogenous as possible with respect to AADT.In theory, each AADT change necessitates the creation of a new road section.In practice, a new road section should be created when the AADT changes by 10 percent or more.Road sections may correspond to major intersections or access points where AADT changes are estimated to exceed 10 percent of the traffic.Knowledge of the road system, and exercise of engineering judgment, may be necessary in some situations.Donut area samples may be split to maintain traffic homogeneity. However, the need to split samples in the future can be minimized by keeping the original donut universe sampling frame sections relatively short in length.
Existing universe sections in donut areas may be used as a sampling frame.However, since they may have been defined according to different criteria, a thorough examination is required to ensure that the section breaks are at reasonable positions along the roadway and appropriately reflect AADT change points.
Precision Level Specification
The objective of the HPMS is to achieve estimates of travel within the donut areas at a 90-10 confidence (precision) level.Most of the total travel for the donut area is developed from the principal arterial universe data (which has no sampling error).The precision of the donut area sample is set at 90-10 to ensure that the travel developed from the expanded sample will meet this objective.While travel for the lower level systems (local and minor collector) is determined from procedures external to the HPMS and has an unknown precision level, it represents very little of the total travel in the donut area.
Donut Area Sample Selection Process
The donut area sample selection process consists of:
Each of these steps is discussed in detail in the following paragraphs.
Determining Stratum Variability
The determination of sample size is dependent on the variability of the characteristic to be measured –AADT, in this case.The basic purpose of the sample is to estimate travel and the only characteristic available to estimate sampling frame variability is AADT.Variability is estimated by computing the coefficient of variation (C.V.) of AADT.The C.V. is the ratio of the standard deviation to the mean.
A preliminary estimate of the C.V. for the established traffic volume groups can be determined by estimating the standard deviation as one-sixth of the range, and the mean as the midpoint of the range.For example, for Volume Group 1, the standard deviation is estimated at 417 (dividing the range 2,500 by 6), the mean is estimated at 1,250 (the midpoint of the range between 1 and 2,499), and the C.V. is .33 (417/1,250).C.V. estimates from this procedure assume a normal distribution throughout the range, which is not likely to be the case for traffic volumes.If, for example, the mean were 1,000 rather than 1,250, the C.V. estimate would be .42.Since sample size is directly related to the C.V., the use of these conservative values help to ensure achievement of the desired precision.
Assuming that the AADT values assigned to each section are fairly accurate, estimates of the C.V., the standard deviation, and the mean are common values that can be computed directly from the sampling frame using HPMS software or other spreadsheet, database or statistical packages.
Determining Stratum Sample Size
The procedures and equations for determining stratum sample size are included in Appendix D.The values to be used for the donut area sample size calculation are:
A sample size calculation must be done for each donut panel stratum that contains universe sections.The minimum number of samples in each stratum is three; if less than three sections exist in a stratum, sample all.
Once a sample size is determined for each stratum, all standard sample sections for the donut functional systems are reviewed to determine how many fall within the specific donut area.A map of the donut area marked with the location of existing standard sample sections may be useful in making this review.The number of supplementary samples required is the difference between the stratum sample size computed in the previous step and the number of standard samples available.For example, if the computed sample size in the first donut area stratum is 50 and 30 standard samples are available, then 20 supplementary samples are needed.
Random Sample Selection Process
The standard sample sections should be eliminated from each universe sampling frame stratum prior to selecting the supplementary sample. This will require identifying the standard samples, establishing the termini points of each section, and appropriately reducing the universe sampling frame stratum size.The existing standard sample stratum sections will reduce an equal number of universe sampling frame stratum sections. For example, if 30 standard sample sections are available in a stratum and 500 sections existed in the universe sampling frame for the same stratum, the modified universe sampling frame stratum will consist of 470 sections.
The supplementary sample is selected using simple random sampling procedures.The selection procedure can be applied after the modified universe sampling frame stratum is prepared by using computerized selection techniques available with most statistical packages or by using the manual method described below.
Manual method:After removal of the standard sample sections, all road sections remaining in the universe sampling frame stratum are assigned a unique, sequential number beginning with the number 1. If the universe sampling frame for a particular stratum has 500 remaining sections, for example, then numbers 1 through 500 are assigned to the sections available for sampling.
At this point, use a table of random numbers to select the supplementary sample from the universe sampling frame; discard duplicate or missing random numbers or random numbers out of the universe sampling frame stratum range. Repeat this step until the number of required supplementary samples plus the number of existing standard samples is at least equal to the required sample size for each stratum.
Judging the Validity of the Sample
The manner in which the donut area sample panel is selected does not follow a strictly theoretical random sampling application.A random standard sample from one sampling frame has been combined with a random supplementary sample from another.When the donut sample is larger than the existing standard sample and the supplementary sample has been picked randomly, the result will likely be a fairly representative sample panel. However, when the supplementary sample is small or nonexistent due to the availability of many standard samples, the resulting combined sample may not be statistically representative of the donut area.This is more likely to occur in large donut areas covering several small urban areas or large rural areas, and may result in biased estimates of travel.
As a validity check, the standard and supplementary sample section locations should be reviewed on a map of the donut area.If the combined donut area sample is not well dispersed over the geography and routes of the donut area, or if sampled sections are concentrated in one part of the area such as in the small urban areas or in one sector of the donut area, then the sample panel may not be representative.
A determination of the validity of the donut area sample panel must be made; if the donut area sample is not representative, then steps should be taken to reselect supplementary samples or increase the sample size.
Computation of Donut Expansion Factors
The donut area sample panel uses its own volume groups and expansion factors to produce the desired travel estimates.The HPMS sample methodology expands the sample based on the ratio of universe length to sample length for each sample stratum.This process results in a single computation for each stratum and allows simple checking since expansion factors are unique for each stratum.For example, if the stratum universe length is 250 and the stratum sample length is 50, the donut area expansion factor for the stratum is 5 (250/50).This expansion procedure provides a clear length check; when the sample length is computed and expanded, it must equal the universe length for the stratum.The sum of the expanded lengths for each volume group in the donut minor arterial and collector systems must equal the total universe length for the donut functional systems.
The HPMS donut area sample section that is also a standard sample section has two expansion factors.The standard sample expansion factor is used to expand data in the standard sample; the donut area expansion factor is used to expand the sample section AADT to an estimate of travel for the donut functional system.
Estimating Total Travel in the Donut Area
Travel estimates within the NAAQS donut area are derived from universe data for the principal arterial functional system; from the combined donut area sample for the rural minor arterial, small urban area minor arterial, rural major collector, and small urban area collector systems; and from State/local summary travel estimates for the small urban and rural local systems and the rural minor collector system.
The travel estimate from universe data is simply computed by multiplying the AADT times the section length for each section and summing the results for all sections.Travel estimates from summary data are used as provided by the States for the rural minor collector and the small urban and rural local systems.The travel estimate from the donut area sampled systems is computed by multiplying the AADT by the section length and by the donut area expansion factor for each sample section and summing these values for all donut area sample sections.The sum of these three estimates is the travel estimate for the donut area portion of the NAAQS nonattainment area.
To obtain the total travel estimate for the NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance area, the urbanized area travel total for the urbanized area(s) contained within the NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance area must be added to the total donut area estimate to obtain the areawide NAAQS nonattainment or maintenance area travel total.
If the required travel estimate is to be stated as an annual (rather than daily) value, the daily result acquired above is to be multiplied by 365 (366 in leap years).
Maintaining the Sample
The universe sampling frame sections and length and sample stratum makeup will change over time and begin to invalidate the sample panel as a result of travel growth, development within the donut area, etc.Several sample maintenance steps are advised: