U.S. Department of Transportation
Federal Highway Administration
1200 New Jersey Avenue, SE
Washington, DC 20590
Federal Highway Administration Research and Technology
Coordinating, Developing, and Delivering Highway Transportation Innovations
|This report is an archived publication and may contain dated technical, contact, and link information|
Publication Number: FHWA-RD-95-197
Date: December 1996
Development of Human Factors Guidelines for Advanced Traveler Information Systems and Commercial Vehicle Operations: Comparable Systems Analysis
CHAPTER 2. SELECTION OF COMPARABLE SYSTEMS FOR ANALYSIS
SELECTING CANDIDATE SYSTEMS
The selection of the comparable systems was accomplished in two phases. The objective of the first phase was to compile a comprehensive list of existing ATIS/CVO-related systems. The list was compiled from several sources: Proceedings of IVHS America Meeting 1993; commercial presentations (booths) at the IVHS America Meetings of 1992 and 1993; ITS Clearinghouse on-line network; literature provided by Task A, Literature Review (Dingus, Hulse, Alves-Foss, Confer, Jahns, Rice, Roberts, Hanowski, and Sorenson, 1993); interviews conducted by Battelle in Task B, Development of Objectives and Performance Requirements (McCallum, Lee, Sanquist, and Wheeler, 1993); and telephone calls following up on prior leads.
In the second phase of the selection process, a total of seven systems were selected for the Comparable Systems Analysis. Two were mandated by the Statement of Work. The remaining five were selected based on the following criteria:
HIGHWAY TRANSPORTATION ATIS SYSTEMS
Two ATIS systems, TravTek and UMTRI, were required by the SOW. In addition, a similar system, Navmate, was selected.
The TravTek System
Travel Technology (TravTek) is an in-vehicle route planning and navigation system manufactured by General Motors.
The comparable systems analysis of TravTek was unique in that the TravTek operational field test was recently completed. Unlike the other ATIS systems, TravTek has been subjected to more than 1.6 million km of user testing. An in-depth field test on this system commenced in Orlando, Florida, in 1992, in which TravTek was installed in 100 cars (75 were rental cars) and participants were surveyed after they returned the rental cars. Twenty-five cars were used for research and development testing. The TravTek field test is the largest evaluation of an ATIS system to date in the United States. It was anticipated that the initial TravTek research, in addition to available knowledge about the TravTek design process, would provide the greatest number and most relevant ATIS lessons. Therefore, this section contains data not only on lessons learned in the design and development of TravTek, but on valuable lessons learned from the initial results of the TravTek field tests (based on the participation of one of the authors in that evaluation).
The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute (UMTRI)
Under the sponsorship of the FHWA, UMTRI has performed a series of laboratory and field studies over the past 4 years on the development of in-vehicle interfaces for driver information systems. The emphasis in Advanced Traveler Information Systems (ATIS) has been in the design of the controls and displays, the presentation logic, and the sequencing of information. Dr. Paul Green of the UMTRI Human Factors Division has directed much of this research, and approximately 16 reports are being submitted to FHWA. The objectives of the UMTRI program of research are to "develop a safe and easy-to-use in-car traffic information system and guidelines, and methods for their evaluation" (Paelke, Green, and Wen, 1993).
The Navmate System
Navmate is an in-vehicle route planning and guidance system designed and manufactured by Zexel Corporation. Plans for the first prototype began in 1989 and it was developed in 2 years. It was included as an additional ATIS system in this study because it was very accessible. Five Avis rental cars in San Jose, California, are currently instrumented with the Navmate system; this allows analysts to perform an informal usability study on the system. Navmate will be installed in another 95 rental vehicles in the next year to expand this data collection effort. This data will be used to evaluate the interface, features, and functions of the current prototype, and to improve the system in the next prototype.
HIGHWAY TRANSPORTATION CVO SYSTEMS
Two systems were selected to obtain lessons learned in the application of in-vehicle display systems to CVO. One system was selected directly from the commercial vehicle domain. The other was introduced because it applied ATIS technology to emergency service vehicles.
The OmniTRACS System
OmniTRACS is an on-board, two-way communication system developed by QUALCOMM. It was first installed in a commercial trucking fleet of 5,000 vehicles in 1988 and now exists in over 50,000 trucks. It is a two-way, satellite-based data link system between drivers and dispatchers. While it was not intended to be a route planning or navigation system, it does have that capability. This system enabled the analyst to learn lessons about methods for displaying, entering, and retrieving information with an in-cab system, as well as methods for storing and retrieving information for a large trucking fleet, and methods for communicating between a commercial vehicle and a control center (i.e., dispatcher).
The analysis of this CVO system provided insightful information and lessons learned in the design and development of driver-dispatcher communication systems in the trucking industry. Since this system has been available in the commercial market since 1988, additional lessons were discovered concerning the deployment of this system that will have to be addressed by future ATIS systems in order to penetrate the commercial market.
The TravelPilot System
The in-vehicle component of the TravelPilot system evolved from an earlier ETAK product named Navigator. Navigator was intended to provide information regarding the current position of a vehicle and a destination referenced to the road system. TravelPilot then evolved as a product for commercial applications that featured route selection and two-way communication to a dispatch centerðCfunctions that were not available in the consumer-targeted Navigator system. TravelPilot by ETAK is currently installed and used in trucks from the Seattle Fire Department. This on-board display system provides a communications link between emergency response vehicles (e.g., fire engines) and the Seattle Fire Department Dispatch Center.
The information on this system originated from the following levels of analysis: reviewing a chapter from the Seattle Fire Department Computer-Aided Dispatch System manual on the Automatic Vehicle Location Operations; on-site visit of the Seattle Fire Department Dispatch Center made by Battelle Seattle Research Center personnel in which the operation of the system was observed; and interviews with managers, dispatchers, and drivers.
NON-HIGHWAY TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS
Two of the selected systems were required to be non-highway transportation systems. The selection of these systems also was based on the criteria described above to ensure that the systems would provide information relevant to ATIS/CVO applications. A number of major areas were investigated (e.g., maritime, aerospace, aviation, and nuclear power) to determine the feasibility of contributing to Task D objectives. The criteria of accessibility eliminated many potential systems that were either proprietary or still in the planning and research stages. In the end, the area of advanced rotorcraft navigation systems seemed to best fulfill the selection criteria.
Crew Station Research and Development Facility (CSRDF)
This advanced rotorcraft simulator at the NASA Ames Research Center includes a number of technological features, such as head-tracked helmet-mounted display, digital map, touchscreen technology, voice interaction, and dynamic information flow. The pilot-vehicle interface was designed by a team of human factors specialists working for the Army Aeroflightdynamics Directorate and the simulator facility was manufactured by CAE Electronics. This system was accessible to analysts and fulfilled several of the selection criteria in terms of aided navigation using digital maps.
The Sikorsky Cognitive Decision-Aiding System
This system features a digital map that incorporates the output of a cognitive decision-aiding system to assist the rotorcraft pilot in selecting alternate mission plans and routes. This system incorporates advanced display technology and navigation decision aiding-features of direct relevance to ATIS/CVO.
COMMENTS ON SYSTEMS NOT SELECTED
The lessons learned and guidelines presented as a result of this analysis are based on a small sample of existing systems. Several other candidate systems may provide excellent material for lessons learned. To verify and extend the recommendations and lessons learned from this analysis, other systems could be investigated in greater detail. The ATIS-related systems that could be explored further include the following:
The "corridors" are undergoing operational testing and are composed of "intelligent highways" and Traffic Management Centers (TMC's). These systems involve monitoring traffic conditions (e.g., volume, vehicle flow, speed, congestion) from various highway and in-vehicle sensors, and highway videotape. Lessons regarding two-way, real-time information flow and corresponding effects on in-vehicle interface are worthy of detailed analysis to produce additional human-interface guidelines.
Other non-highway systems also could provide additional information. Some worthy candidates are:
Topics: research, safety
Keywords: research, safety, Advanced Traveler Information Systems (ATIS), Commercial Vehicle Operations (CVO), Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS), Intelligent Vehicle-Highway Systems (IVHS)